Proundly Supported by
Pfizer Foundation
    Home | Current Issue | Past Issue | Board | Instruction | Contact


Arthroscopically Assisted Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction: Comparison of Bone-Patellar Tendon-Bone Versus Hamstring Tendon Autograft

1100

Tanarat Boonriong MD*,
Niran Kietsiriroje MD*

* Department of Orthopaedic Surgery and Physical Medicine. Faculty of Medicine,
Prince of Songkla University

Abstract


Background : The bone-patellar tendon-bone (BPTB) and the hamstring tendons are commonly used for arthroscopially-assisted anterior cruciate ligament(ACL) reconstruction.
Purpose : To compare the results of arthroscopically-assisted ACL reconstruction using bone-patellar tendon-
bone and hamstring tendons grafts in terms of postoperative knee stability, knee functions and clinical rating scale, and patient satisfaction.
Hypothesis : There was no difference in the outcomes of the two grafts.
Study Design : Retrospective non-randomized clinical trial.
Material and Method : Two groups of patients, 45 in the BPTB group and 30 in the hamstring group, were followed for at least one year.
Results : The two groups had similar pre-operative data except the hamstring group which had a significantly shorter duration of injury before operation (9.5 versus 18 months, p < 0.05). There was no difference in median pre-operative Lysholm knee score (74 in the BPTB group versus 75 in the hamstring group, p > 0.05) and the post-operative one (95 in the BPTB group versus 99 in the hamstring group, p > 0.05). There was also no difference in the median pre-operative HSS knee score (58 in the BPTB group versus 61 in the hamstring group, p > 0.05). Although there was a statistically significant difference in the median post-operative HSS knee score between the two groups (95 in the BPTB group versus 96 in the hamstring group, p < 0.05), this was not clinically significant since both scores were rated as an excellent result. Both groups had a significantly improved knee stability and knee functions (Lysholm and HSS knee scores). The hamstring group, however, had significantly higher patient satisfaction (88% in the BPTB group versus 93% in the hamstring group, p < 0.05).
Conclusion : Both the BPTB and the hamstring tendon grafts resulted in significantly improved knee stability and functions with high patient satisfaction. The hamstring tendon group, however, had a significantly better post-operative patient satisfaction (Visual Analog Scale,VAS).

Keyword : Anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction, Bone-patellar tendon-bone, Hamstring tendon



Download Full Paper
  Vol87_No9_1100.pdf  [ 84.80 Kb]

Home | Current Issue | Past Issue | Board | Instruction | Contact

© Copyright The Medical Association of Thailand. All Rights Reserved.2001-2002
Acquista Cialis generico 5 mg Effetti collaterali del Cialis 5 mg Acquista Cialis 20mg online Prezzo di Cialis originale in Svizzera Acquista Viagra in Svizzera senza prescrizione Dove comprare Cialis 10mg Viagra in farmacia online effetti collaterali Costo di Cialis 5mg Opiniones de Reduslim Acquista Spedra Avanafil senza prescrizione Acquista Viagra in Svizzera senza prescrizione Comprar Cialis original Comprar Viagra Contrareembolso Cialis 5mg Viagra sin receta Cialis 5 mg efectos secundarios graves Reduslim precio Trastorno de la ereccin venta de tadalafilo avanafil prezzo cialis 20 mg prezzo cialis effetti benefici cialis 10 mg Reduslim Kaufen pulse crypto price prediction avanafil 100 mg prezzo buy cialis or generic tadalafil 9 http://diplomsagroups.com https://gosznac-diploma.com/ http://sreestrom.ru/ http://originality-diplomy.com https://russian-diplom.com 9 http://russdiplomiki.com https://diplomansy.com 11 https://diploms-asx.com http://diplomrussian.com 11 https://rudiplomisty24.com/ https://russiany-diploman.com/ https://land-diplom.com/ 11 https://kyc-diplom.com http://diploms-service.com https://originaly-dokuments.com https://diplomy-grup24.com/ http://aurus-diploms.com/kupit-diplom-stroitelya.html 9 https://diplomansy.com/kupit-diplom-s-reestrom http://diploms-service.com/diplomy-po-gorodam/novosibirsk 11 http://diplomyland.com/ https://premialnie-diplomansy.com https://diplomiki.com
https://aurus-diplomany.com
https://russiany-diplomana.com
https://originality-diplomik.com
https://lands-diplomy.com
https://okdiplom.com/
https://nsk-diplom.com/
https://ry-diplom.com/
https://diploms-vuza.com/
https://diplom-bez-problem.com/
https://kazdiplomas.com/
https://diplomoz-197.com/
https://kupit-diplomyz24.com/
https://prodiplome.com/
https://diplom5.com/
https://10000diplomov.ru/
https://1magistr.ru/
https://diplom-insti.ru/
https://kdiplom.ru/
https://diplom45.ru/
https://diplom-zakaz.ru/
https://peoplediplom.ru/
https://diplom-profi.ru/
https://bisness-diplom.ru/
https://kupite-diplom0024.ru/
11
11
11
https://diploman-asx.com
11
https://rudiplomirovany.com
https://premialnie-diploms.com
https://diplomans-doc.com
https://russiany-diplom.com
https://diplomy-gruppa.com
https://rudiplomis.com
https://rudiplomisty.com/
https://lands-diploms.com
https://originality-diploman.com
https://originality-diplomx24.com
https://originality-diploms24.com
https://originality-diploma24.com
https://originality-diploman24.com
https://originality-diplomans24.com
https://originality-diplomik24.com
https://originality-diplomix24.com
https://originality-diplomas24.com
9
https://originality-diplomiks24.com
https://originality-diplomiki24.com
https://ru-diplomirovan.com
https://ru-diplomirovany.com
www.ru-diplomirovanay.com
https://ru-diplomirovannie.com
rudiplomir.com
rudiplomirs.com
www.rudiplomira.com
rudiplomiry.com
https://rudiplomiru.com
ab-diplom24.ru
www.ab-diplom24.ru
http://www.24diplom07.ru
http://landik-attestats365.com
http://study-diploms.com}
9
11
9
http://diplomsagroups.com/kupit-diplom-o-srednem-obrazovanii/diplom-o-srednem-i-srednem-specialnom-obrazovanii.html
11
http://diplomsagroups.com/kupit-attestat-shkoly.html
https://premialnie-diplomansy.com/----/
https://premialnie-diplomansy.com/----/
https://premialnie-diplomansy.com/--/
https://russiany-diplomans.com/attestat-9-klassov
https://russiany-diplomans.com/srednee-spetsialnoe-obrazovanie
https://russiany-diplomans.com/kupit-diplom-kolledzha
https://russiany-diplomans.com/diplom-magistra
http://lands-diploms.com/ http://lands-diploms.com/specialnosti/yurist.html http://lands-diploms.com/goroda/krasnodar.html http://lands-diploms.com/goroda/omsk.html http://lands-diploms.com/goroda/chelyabinsk.html
http://aurus-diploms.com/attestat-9-klass.html http://aurus-diploms.com/obrazovanie/kupit-diplom-s-zaneseniem-v-reestr.html http://aurus-diploms.com/diplom-magistra.html http://aurus-diploms.com/geography/kupit-diplom-v-samare.html
http://radiploma.com/kupit-diplom-s-reestrom http://radiploma.com/kupit-diplomy-tehnikuma-kolledzha http://radiploma.com/kupit-diplomy-o-srednem-tehnicheskom-obrazovanii http://radiploma.com/kupit-diplom-kosmetologa
https://aurus-diplomans.com http://www.diplomas-asx.com https://diplomana-asx.com www.rusd-diplom.com https://rusd-diploms.com https://aurus-diplomany.com https://aurus-diplomik.com www.aurus-diplomas.com https://diplomans-asx.com diplomany-asx.com http://www.diplomys-asx.com https://diploman-servise.com http://www.radiploms.com http://www.radiplom.com radiplomy.com radiploma.com rudiplomisty24.com/--- http://www.rudiplomisty24.com/--- www.rudiplomisty24.com/--- rudiplomisty24.com/--
www.originality-diploman.com/----- originality-diploman.com/- originality-diploman.com/- www.originality-diploman.com/--
www.gosznac-diplomy.com/kupit-diplom-o-srednem-texnicheskom-obrazovanii www.gosznac-diplomy.com/diplom-spetcialista https://gosznac-diplomy.com/kupit-diplom-v-cheliabinske
diploman-asx.com/kupit-diplom-moskva https://diploman-asx.com/otzyvy http://www.diploman-asx.com/kupit-diplom-bakalavra-ili-specialista https://diploman-asx.com/kupit-diplom-specialista
11
http://www.diplom-belarus.com
diplomi-price.com
edu-digest.ru
http://proobzh.ru
http://www.edu-nt.ru/
http://www.student-madi.ru
http://dof-edu.ru
9
http://proobzh.ru
www.krsk-school47.ru http://www.russdiplomik.com/kupit-diplom-v-moskve.html russdiplomik.com/diplom-farmaczevta.html russdiplomik.com/diplom-s-reestrom-o-vyisshem-obrazovanii.html http://www.russdiplomik.com/kupit-diplom-v-novosibirske.html
http://www.russdiplomik.com/diplom-czena.html www.russdiplomik.com/diplom-farmaczevta.html russdiplomik.com/kupit-diplom-sankt-peterburg.html russdiplomik.com/kupit-diplom-v-ekaterinburge.html https://russiany-diplomans.com/diplom-o-srednem-obrazovanii http://www.russiany-diplomans.com/kupit-diplom-vracha www.russiany-diplomans.com/kupit-diplom-ekaterinburg http://www.russiany-diplomans.com/kupit-diplom-pskov https://arena-diplom24.com/attestaty https://arena-diplom24.com/diplomy-po-spetsialnosti/diplom-yurista https://ryazan.arena-diplom24.com/ http://www.novorossijsk.arena-diplom24.com/ www.diploms-goznak.com/attestat-vechernej-shkoly http://diploms-goznak.com/kupit-diplom-v-dnepropetrovske http://www.diploms-goznak.com/kupit-diplom-v-zhitomire http://diploms-goznak.com/kupit-diplom-v-zaporozhe - www.diploms-goznak.com/kupit-diplom-v-odesse diploms-goznak.com/vrach www.diploms-goznak.com/diplom-uchilishcha www.diploms-goznak.com/diplom-starogo-obraztsa http://www.diploms-goznak.com/diplom-tekhnikuma-kolledzha diploms-goznak.com/farmatsevt diploms-goznak.com/yurist http://diploms-goznak.com/meditsinskij-diplom diploms-goznak.com/svidetelstvo-o-rozhdenii
https://diplomy-servise.com
diploman-dok.com
diploman-doks.com
diploman-doky.com
www.diploman-doku.com http://education-ua.com/kupit-legalnyij-diplom-v-ukraine.html
www.education-ua.com/attestat-diplom.html
education-ua.com/zaporozhe.html
education-ua.com/kieve.html
http://education-ua.com/odesse.html
http://education-ua.com/summah.html
9
http://education-ua.com/ternopole.html
education-ua.com/diplom-o-mediczinskom-obrazovanii.html
http://www.education-ua.com/diplom-vyisshee.html
http://education-ua.com/kupit-nastoyashhij-diplom-goznak.html
http://www.education-ua.com/
education-ua.com/diplom-texnikuma-kolledzha.html
education-ua.com/diplom-magistra-ukrainskogo-vuza.html
http://www.education-ua.com/diplom-o-mediczinskom-obrazovanii.html
http://www.education-ua.com/diplom-medsestry.html
www.education-ua.com/diplom-nedorogo.html
http://education-ua.com/kupit-diplom-novogo-obrazca.html
www.education-ua.com/otzivi-pogelania.html
www.education-ua.com/diplom-vyisshee.html
http://education-ua.com/diplom-uchilishha.html
http://education-ua.com/diplom-s-registracziej.html
http://www.education-ua.com/kupit-diplom-s-provodkoj-v-ukraine.html
http://www.education-ua.com/diplom-specialista-ukrainskogo-vuza.html
http://www.education-ua.com/diplom-uchilishha.html
http://www.education-ua.com/kupit-diplom-sssr-na-nastoyashhem-blanke.html
http://education-ua.com/svidetelstvo-o-rozhdenii.html
11
http://education-ua.com/svidetelstvo-o-smerti.html
education-ua.com/svidetelstvo-o-brake.html
www.education-ua.com/svidetelstvo-o-razvode.html http://rudiplomisty24.com/-11- https://diplomy-servise.com http://dipplomy.com www.egpu.ru http://vina-net.ru/ cursovik.ru www.spravkipiter.ru alcoself.ru www.school625.ru www.moek-college.ru www.mmcmedclinic.ru www.intimvisit.ru http://med-pravo.ru/ http://moskva-medcentr.ru/ intim-72.ru razigrushki.ru www.dgartschool.ru www.ftbteam.ru http://sb26.ru/ http://www.originaly-dokuments.com/attestaty/attestat-za-9-klass https://originaly-dokuments.com/diplom-o-srednem-spetsialnom-obrazovanii https://originaly-dokuments.com/gorod/nizhnij-tagil https://originaly-dokuments.com/gorod/vologda www.originaly-dokuments.com/gorod/saratov https://originaly-dokuments.com/spetsialnosti/yurist originaly-dokuments.com/spetsialnosti/povar www.originaly-dokuments.com/gorod/krasnodar originaly-dokuments.com/attestaty/attestat-za-11-klass http://www.originaly-dokuments.com/gorod/ekaterinburg www.originaly-dokuments.com/attestaty https://originaly-dokuments.com/spetsialnosti/bukhgalter www.originaly-dokuments.com/gorod/omsk originaly-dokuments.com/gorod/novosibirsk www.originaly-dokuments.com/gorod/sankt-peterburg originaly-dokuments.com/gorod/chelyabinsk www.originaly-dokuments.com/gorod/orjol originaly-dokuments.com/diplom-o-vysshem-obrazovanii/diplom-bakalavra originaly-dokuments.com/diplom-o-vysshem-obrazovanii/diplom-magistra www.originaly-dokuments.com/spetsialnosti/menedzher https://originaly-dokuments.com/diplom-o-srednem-spetsialnom-obrazovanii/diplom-kolledzha https://originaly-dokuments.com/diplom-o-srednem-spetsialnom-obrazovanii
- - - -- - - premialnie-diplomansy.com https://premialnie-diplomansy.com/--/ www.premialnie-diplomansy.com www.originality-diploman.com originality-diploman.com https://originality-diploman.com/-- originality-diploman.com https://originality-diploman.com/-- https://originality-diploman.com/---- www.originality-diploman.com http://https://originality-diploman.com/-- premialnie-diplomansy.com originality-diploman.com www.premialnie-diplomansy.com premialnie-diplomansy.com https://premialnie-diplomansy.com/--/ https://premialnie-diplomansy.com/--/ www.premialnie-diplomansy.com www.premialnie-diplomansy.com http://https://originality-diploman.com/--
9
www.gosznac-diplomy.com http://https://gosznac-diplomy.com/kupit-diplom-vuza-rossii http://https://gosznac-diplomy.com/diplom-sredne-spetcialnoe-obrazovanie http://https://gosznac-diplomy.com/kupit-diplom-v-moskve gosznac-diplomy.com gosznac-diplomy.com https://gosznac-diplomy.com/svidetelstvo-o-rozhdenii http://https://gosznac-diplomy.com/diplom-feldshera gosznac-diplomy.com https://gosznac-diplomy.com/diplom-stroitelya
9 9 11
originality-diplomans.com
rudiplomis24.com
www.diploma-asx.com
https://gosznac-diplom.com/ diploman-doci.com
https://originality-diplomans.com/
www.rudiplomis24.com
https://lands-diplom.com/
https://gosznac-diplom.com/ http://https://aurus-diplom.com/
https://originality-diplomans.com/
https://rudiplomista24.com/
www.diploma-asx.com
https://gosznac-diplom.com/ https://aurus-diplom.com/
http://https://originality-diplomans.com/
https://rudiplomista24.com/
https://lands-diplom.com/
www.gosznac-diplom.com http://https://aurus-diplom.com/
http://diplomsagroups.com/diplomy-po-specialnosti/diplom-buhgaltera.html www.originality-diploman24.com https://originality-diplomans.com/ https://originality-diploma24.com/- http://https://frees-diploma.com https://ekaterinburg.arena-diplomi24.com/ http://https://ekaterinburg.arena-diplomi24.com/